First Amendment or Legal Case?

Screen Shot 2014-07-21 at 11.03.42 AMFirst Amendment or Legal Case?

If you could sue over a bad review, would you?

Some businesses have been successfully doing just that. A recent judgement in France has US bloggers on alert. Restaurants have had random success suing professional food critics for libel in the past, what makes this one different is that the amateur blogger, Ms. Caroline Doudet, has only 3,000 followers, compared to a newspaper or magazine food critic with over 100k readers.

Personal blogs and review sites such as Yelp have changed the complaint game. Criticisms amongst friends are now online, viewable by anyone who does a search. Does the “potential” threat of lost business turn a negative review into reprehensible slander? We have all seen reviews that are clearly off base and rude, but even those, are they lawsuit material?

Earlier this year, Virginia contractor Dietz Development LLC  won a judgement of slander against a homeowner who wrote a scathing Yelp review in 2011. The homeowner, Jane Perez, complained of “shoddy” work, damages to her home, and that Dietz didn’t have a license. She also accused the crew of stealing her jewelry. Dietz claimed defamation, sued, and won. However, the courts denied his damages claim of approximately $750,000, finding him guilty of posting defamatory responses.

What if the reviews don’t claim illegal behavior? The First Amendment grants consumers free speech rights to complain about bad service, doesn’t it?

In January, The Virginia Court of Appeals said no, ruling against seven customers of a carpet cleaning service in Alexandria. Unhappy, they complained on Yelp, but the business owner, Joe Hadeed, claimed the reviews were false because the reviewers’ profile names didn’t match customers in his database.

The judge, William G. Petty, agreed that free speech wasn’t relevant, stating “the review is not an opinion, instead, the review is based on a false statement.”.

Yelp is now required to turn over user information associated with such cases. They responded that the judgement, an attempt “to silence online critics”, failed “to adequately protect free speech rights on the Internet”.

If a service is truly flawed, should a guest have the right to say so? The courts might be saying no. French blogger Ms. Doudet didn’t hide her identity or claim theft. She stated service was inattentive, something the manager himself recognizes was a possibility.

He agreed that, ”Maybe there were some errors in the service, that happens sometimes in the middle of August – I recognise that.”

Speaking to Arret Sur Images, the manager stated, “People can criticise, but there is a way of doing it – with respect. That was not the case here.”

The 6 month old review, entitled “the place to avoid in Cap-Ferret: Il Giardino” , was claimed to cause “great harm” because it appeared 4th in Google search.

The manager stated that because it was in Google, it “did my business more and more harm, even though we have worked seven days a week for 15 years. I could not accept that.”

Are hurt feelings enough of a reason for a lawsuit?

French law allows a judge to make a judgement of slander if a casual relationship tying the potential for harm to the defendant’s review is identified, regardless of review’s facts. Therefore Il Giardino did not need to prove loss of business, or dispute claims, only the potential to harm. The judge found the post title to be defamatory, ordering it changed to reduce prominence in Google, and fining Ms. Doudet approximately $3,400 US dollars. Ms. Doudet deleted the post.

Is the publicity surrounding a case worse than the original review? In trying to silence one bad review, it gets republished in all press about the case, gaining more readers, rather than less. Even if a business wins, the lawsuit might make guests question the validity of the review. Why not just ignore it? It’s  ONLY one review, right?

What about false reviews by a vindictive former employee, competitor, or ex? It happens, but not often. Is the best response to sift for truth, improve staff training if needed, but otherwise ignore the bad reviews?

The problem with these lawsuits is said best by Ms. Doudet,  ”If bloggers do not have the freedom to write negative reviews, positive reviews make no sense either.”


8 Responses to First Amendment or Legal Case?

  1. father's day shirt card video November 18, 2017 at 12:17 am #

    Nice post mate, keep up the great work, just shared this with my friendz

  2. father's day shirt project November 19, 2017 at 5:22 am #

    I am typically to blogging and that i actually appreciate your articles. This great article has really peaks my interest. My goal is to bookmark your web blog and keep checking for brand new details.

  3. Itamar Serp November 20, 2017 at 8:37 am #

    Unquestionably believe that which you said. Your favorite justification appeared to be on the net the easiest thing to be aware of. I say to you, I definitely get annoyed while people think about worries that they just do not know about. You managed to hit the nail upon the top and also defined out the whole thing without having side effect , people could take a signal. Will likely be back to get more. Thanks|

  4. father's day shirt and tie card step by step November 20, 2017 at 2:09 pm #

    very good put up, i certainly love this web site, keep on it

  5. instagram likes November 20, 2017 at 4:45 pm #

    Thanks for your personal marvelous posting! I definitely enjoyed reading it, you
    might be a great author.I will always bookmark your blog and will come back later on. I want to encourage
    continue your great posts, have a nice day!

  6. ????????????? November 20, 2017 at 5:00 pm #

    Hiya very nice web site!! Man .. Excellent
    .. Superb .. I’ll bookmark your site and take the
    feeds additionally? I’m happy to seek out numerous useful information here within the post, we need work out more techniques in this regard, thanks for sharing.
    . . . . .

  7. day tours kuala lumpur November 21, 2017 at 2:41 am #

    I blog frequently and I seriously appreciate your content.
    The article has really peaked my interest. I am going to book
    mark your site and keep checking for new details about once per week.
    I subscribed to your RSS feed too.

  8. father's day red sox shirt November 21, 2017 at 8:12 am #

    I am also writing to let you be aware of what a cool discovery my wife’s daughter went through studying your web page. She realized several things, which include what it’s like to possess an amazing giving spirit to get the others without problems grasp chosen complex subject areas. You undoubtedly exceeded visitors’ expected results. Thank you for coming up with those effective, trustworthy, informative and as well as cool thoughts on that topic to Emily.

Leave a Reply